Saturday, January 9, 2010

Birds of Prey: Issues #62 to #75 [Feb 04 - Dec 04]

Year six and we are past the half of the 127 issues total. Gail Simone has established herself as the ruling deity in this universe and weaves one dangerous arc after another in perfect escalation and with no power subtracted whatsoever. The affinity to danger and unorthodox team-ups only leads to a spicier reading flavor and the art has been stellar. It’s fan boy heaven all the way for me.

The Huntress has been integrated as core member so the scope of the missions can broaden due to the increased manpower and Simone definitely explores the possibilities to push these ladies to the limits. For starters we have a central arc for each of the trio, starting with Oracle, who is in jeopardy once again, when Savant teams up with the Senator Pullman [mentioned in the last review] in order to flush her out and learn the super-hacker’s true identity. Barbara is interrogated along with other technically gifted women from Gotham, who fit Oracle’s profile and has to make an escape. Not the easiest thing in the world, when you need a wheelchair to get by, but we are treated an encore deserving performance that is both plausible and exciting.

Next stop we have the Black Canary, who travels to Japan to meet her martial arts sensei, who is on deathbed, but a peaceful saying of goodbyes leads to manhunt as Dinah teams up with the top assassin in the DC universe, Lady Shiva, to track down her sensei’s murderer. The prime suspect is Chesire [an oldie for this series], who has upgraded her reputation to Poison Princess. With such a formidable foe, who denies the crime and blames Senator Pullman for a frame, cane the Birds of Prey be sure that they are on the right track? There is backstabbing, intrigues about Chesire’s past are revealed and most naturally people do die.

The third arc is all about Huntress on her first solo mission as the lead and not second violin, which is a task Oracle has given her with strategic purpose. It concerns a certain sect that is behind the suicides of teens dressed as dead teen superheroes. The compound is led by a man with the power to mind control the children and serves the biggest DC villain ever, Brainiac. Huntress has to fight against Vixen [DC heroine with the power to channel animals] and then against a whole team of metahuman super heroes, who have gone MIA at one point. At the same the battle escalates to a new level as Barbara has to withstand against Brainiac himself in a virtual battle and not get possessed.

As you can see there is much plot involved and intricate plot with layers upon layers, which have to be mentioned in order for me to make you understand, where I am coming from with this adoration for the series. For starters, strategic warfare has been elevated to a dangerous warfare and the chess moves villains make against the heroes and vice verse held my breath. It was the mind games, blocks and traps that built the atmosphere and there is plenty of that, while the hand-to-hand combat and super power abuse is what pumps the adrenaline.

Then there are the behind-the-scenes stolen glimmers, which add color, dimension, moral complexity and dimensions to the adventures. Super heroes are people after all, they are not their powers and they cannot be saving the world 24-7. They crack, they break rules, they take the unfavorable odds and work with them, even if that means crossing lines and be in that undefined grey area. Simone does that to these women [and occasionally men]. She sets out to see whether second chances are worth giving as seen with Savant and Creole’s enrollment in the roster, when Oracle was in Pullman’s hands. The exploration of Savant is an interesting one as he is one of the generally conflicted people, who are messed up enough to be chaotic in his doing, unpredictable to a point.

With Savant on the team can Black Canary, now that she is more powerful than him after her numerous training sessions, hold off her anger and accept him and the chance given to him by Oracle? Can Huntress hold off her violence and show mercy, even when undeserved, but which is important as a cardinal rule for being a hero and not just a masked vigilante? Can Oracle really bring all three together as a team? These are just the core questions that are only partially answered and are left off for further issues.

But these can’t be explored, unless the setting is changed and the girls are taken off from their comfort zone. Gail is pretty radical in her decision to relocate the operation after making Oracle blow her Clock Tower and computers to save herself and Batman, when she’s attacked and the solution to the housing problem comes in the shape of a technologically pimped plane called Aerie One with one heck of a pilot and a new member aka Zinda Blake aka Lady Blackhawk, time traveling military pilot from WWII.

In one word: awesome.

Art-wise the situation has been more than beneficial. The comic gods have been generous with Ed Benes, Cliff Richards, Joe Bennett, Ron Adrian and Jim Fern. There have been more art teams per arcs, which is always exciting to witness and one way or another these guys did it for me from an aesthetic point of view, which is immensely hard to do. I am a fickle person after all and quite pretentious, capricious and specific in my art preferences. To be honest it can be debated whether or not Fern matched my tastes or not, but compared to other pencillers that have worked on the series, his work is way better.

Verdict: You are losing valuable time. Start reading. Now.

Sabretooth in Art

Evil doer time here on these art posts and next stop is Sabretooth, who is the ying to Logan's yan or something similar. Sabretooth is basically what Wolverine would have looked like, if he had stayed with the Weapon X program and served his purpose. Sabretooth has the same powers like Logan minus the retractable claws and is as tough as Wolverine. Their battles to overpower one another are legendary in the Marvel universe and to be quite honest that is all I know about the guy as far as Marvel history goes. This prompts me into reading more Sabretooth. Anyway here are my art choices.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Novels vs. Comics: Fight!

...actually, the difference between writing comics and novels isn't so much "fight" as "watch them run away from each other at top speed".

I went into writing novels without any noticeable research in how to do it, aside from having read tens of thousands of them over the years. Comics were a much more deliberate process for me: I had a very clear idea that I didn't know how to do it, so I set forth to find out how other people did.

Good thing I did, too, because they're completely different animals. And on one hand, the differences are obvious--scripts vs. prose, frames vs. chapters, 22 pages vs 400 (that's sort of a big one), collaboration vs. individual work--but those obvious differences don't fully address some of the things I found most striking.

As a novelist, everything happens on the page. In comics, all the action is *off* the page, between the frames: you're catching a frozen moment. There can't be both an action and a reaction in the same image; it doesn't work. That's a huge thing for a novelist to adapt to.

Moreover, in novels, chapters and scenes are as long as you want them to be. In comics, a scene is very often just two pages, because turning the page creates a new space and a new scene in a way that white space or chapter breaks do in books. So the pacing for a comic has to be *extremely* deliberate and very tight. Obviously scenes can, and do, go on for longer than two pages--but as a writer, you're still usually looking at a page turn for your scene break...and when you only have 22 pages (the standard for a modern comic) you want to be extremely careful with your storytelling.

Interestingly, the scripting process for comics led me to a habit that's become increasingly helpful for novels. Television and film use something called a "beatsheet", which are just brief, sentence-long descriptions of the most relevant "beats", or scenes, in a show. I adapted that for comics writing, using a beat for *every* scene, in order to more thoroughly control the story structure. It's turned out that a novel-sized beatsheet is exceedingly useful to me, too--less formal than an outline, but more or less of the same nature, it's helped a great deal in moving past sticking points in novels.

So while the two formats are wildly different, it turns out studying one can really prove to be helpful with the other. It's worth the effort, and I'm more than happy to have had the comics experience I've now got. With any luck, I'll do more in the future, and learn even more clever things to bring from one medium to the other!

----

Who: C.E Murphy. I wanted to have C.E. Murphy on my blog for quite some time and back, when her comic book series Take a Chance was announced, I wanted to conduct and interview and get a picture of what’s it like to go from novels to comics. Due to deadline clusters however that was a no-go, until now, when C.E. Murphy [author of the Walker Papers, the Negotiator Trilogy, the Inheritor's Cycle] reveals what’s the difference between writing novels and comic books.

Links: Website & Magical Words [contributor blogger]

Thursday, January 7, 2010

Birds of Prey: Issues #50 to #61 [Feb 03 - Jan 04]

We have reached year five for the Birds of Prey. And guess what? This is the year, when the series comes of age so to say. Gail Simone is the writer-in-charge and it is under her reign that the series become a powerhouse and overall strong line from DC. Artist-wise the activity has slowed down to a more acceptable pace with just two artists changing positions.

Also this is the ideal chance for readers to hop on board without any hindrances to catch the plot without the need to read back issues. After Gail Simone heads the series [Issue #56] an arc serves as a base for further character development and with every mission accomplished the overall story and the trajectory of Oracle’s operation change in a general sense. Ideally the series should have been written by a woman right off the bat, because a team of superheroines can only be cracked psychologically by a woman. Compared to Dixon, Simone expands the series emotional capacity and the interactions between the characters become more genuine, while at the same time the action doesn’t suffer one tiny bit.

However before Gail Simone takes the mantle we have six issues by writer Gilbert Hernandez split in two arcs, one of which did not excite me much, because it mystified science to a point, where it appeared as magic. Black Canary had to deal with Metamorpho [another DC super hero] and his dysfunctional family after a science experiment gone wrong. Thankfully, that was resolved quick and we jump to the secondary plot line, which revolves around Oracle and Danko Twag [the first killer moth]. Hernandez touches upon the importance behind Oracle’s anonymous identity; a theme, which is expanded by Simone.

Under Simone the Birds of Prey add new member to their roster aka the Huntress makes her first appearance as an operative, even if right now she is not on permanent roll. This happens in the best arc so far in the series, which introduces a new antagonistic duo to the mix aka Savant and Creote [master black-mailer and his muscled help]. As the Birds trail a false lead fed to them by Savant, the Black Canary falls in Savant’s trap is captured, maimed and used as a hostage to extract from Barbara Batman’s identity. The Huntress is called in and both manage to survive, even if Dinah has her arm and two legs broken by Savant. The arc was intense, both because the stakes were high and because Gail Simone revisits a crucial piece of information about Dinah’s past, in which she has been held hostage and tortured before.

The arc has a huge impact on the characters and poses important questions. What is Dinah’s emotional wellbeing after reliving an episode that nearly destroyed her in the past? Is Oracle on the right track after keeping Savant’s information data base behind Dinah’s back? Why is a senator targeting the Birds after Savant’s capture and what exactly will Savant’s vengeance be when he tracks down Oracle [because he doesn’t get a long stay at the Arkahm Asylum]?

Some questions are answered. Dinah has taken upon herself to improve her martial arts skills in order to never be in a victim’s position, while Barbara decides to fire her as a measure to keep her safe [but that doesn’t last for long]. However for the rest of the questions one must keep reading on.

Art-wise things have been stable. Casey Jones is the artist, accompanying Gilbert’s writing, but I am left with mixed feelings about the overall impression of the art. In the first arc by Gilbert the lines did not impress me, but when inker John Beatty comes on board for the rest of the six issues, the art improves by a large margin. This is living proof that comic book art is not just the penciller, but it involves inkers, colorists and letterers. Even if an artist appeals to a reader, the other variables in the art department can minimize or maximize that level of appeal.

Along with Simone comes artist Ed Benes, who is possibly the best thing to happen to the series as far as art is considered. He is the whole package that makes me tick as an art fan. His work shows attention to detail, has sharp lines, adds fluidity to motion and explores angles, which is of great importance to fights. Plus, I simply enjoy how he draws the human body and face in the super-hero comic book vein, which I am a total sucker for.

The Verdict: You better start reading from Issue 50 and see for real whether this is not your cup of tea, because the series has reached maturity and along with action, adventure and adrenaline, there is an emotional depth and mad plotting skills involved. This was the point I converted entirely and thought that I had been an idiot to dismiss DC for so long.

Mystique in Art

I want to shift the angle and host some villains on the art train. Mystique came to mind almost immediately, because she is one of the defining Marvel evil doers and terrorists, killing and maiming with almost no clothes on. Her first appearance is in 1978, which makes her a semi-new veteran in the Marvel roster and established herself as a controversial and conniving fox with backstabber tendencies. What I love about Mystique apart from the ability to become any person she desires is the schadenfroh attitude and how she enjoys the messes she whips up. The fact that she is a mother to two of Marvel’s greatest superheroes: Nightcrawler and Rogue [foster mother, but still], brings something extra special when the X-Men fight against her. It is one thing to fight with your parents and another story, when you are trying to save the world and your mother is one of the key terrorists that wreak havoc around. Anyway I scanned DA for art high and low, but found the most inappropriate pictures ever. I barely came across these, which explains the sculpture:

Birds of Prey: Issues #38 to #49 [Feb 02 - Jan 03]

We are now reaching year four and the Birds of Prey are under new management [creatively] all most all the time. Year four marks perhaps the highest rotation of pencillers. Then we have Chuck Dixon writing his last arc for the series and we have a major crossover [by now you should expect this already] that concerns all Bat-related characters. The summary in just this one paragraph suggests elevated dynamics [on and off stage] and the need for stability.

Action: Year four decided to divide itself neatly my three categories, concerning story. Prime example here is the 4 issue The Island Forgotten by Time arc [July/October]. The location is the aforementioned island, which sometimes is in the world and sometimes is not, but makes sure to take a few souvenirs along the way like for instance dinosaurs and WWII warring soldiers, both US and Japanese. Cute picture, eh?

However it’s not a perfect vacationing spot and Black Canary learns this the hard way, when she is sent there during the island’s rare resurfacings. She has to compete with mercenary Deathstroke [Slade], government hired team Eddie Fyers, Connor Hawke [son of Green Arrow] and Camorouge [another mercenary, who is not a DC super star character, so it’s normal, if she doesn’t ring a bell]. The object: miracle cure for autoimmune diseases. This is every boy’s dream arc. We have battles with dinosaurs, back stabbing, martial arts, time paradoxes, prisoners of war, interrogation and even some unexpected sacrifices. Way to go, Dixon.

While on action, the arc provided by writer Terry Moore provides another look on the Birds of Prey, which does not involve time travelling or a planned mission. On a conference, where Lexcorp-funded doctor Atticus Blackaver presents young Madison, a metahuman with the power to control the chaos code aka heal and reverse the process of decay. The innocent front is that through her death and illness will be kicked, where the sun don’t shine, but then again nothing by Lexcorp is ever world-domination free. We have Black Canary fight her way from hired guns to get back to Oracle, while Barbara gives a few roundhouse kicks, after Madison performs a quick healing session.

Cast Development: The character web ensnares more and more victims eh… I mean characters along its way [insert laughter] and I received a better picture about the heroes involved in the series. For instance the early hinted upon secondary plot line concerning Ted Kord and his electronics company is touched upon, expanded and concluded with superhero intermission [aka Power Girl], but also viewed in light of his recent heart condition diagnose and what its effects mean on his recent return from retirement as the Blue Beetle.

Then the reader is left a whole issue to learn Power Girl’s history with Oracle as the very first field operative Barbara has hired. Apart from receiving information about why Power Girl is apprehensive, when communicating with Barbara, we are also treated to a new nuance about Barbara’s character and the mistakes she has made.

Then we jump over to Moore’s arc, where we are treated to Barbara and how she is dealing with the sudden revival of her legs. The issue whether she feels or not powerless as a handicapped person is not touched upon [clearly she is not a victim, even in a wheelchair], but I was shown a bit of the Batgirl that Oracle was, before being put in a wheelchair. That bit certainly added another flavor and as a central character Barbara becomes more irresistible.

Last, but not least, Dinah has been shown to bond with a new teenaged vigilante Spoiler and aid her with family matters. The act, which although not in any case climatic in Dinah’s development, only establishes her as a charitable and humanitarian individual.

The Risk: Yes, the dreaded crossover is the only hazard that jarred my reading. This time the arcs revolved around Bruce Wayne and the issue whether or not the man is a murderer. A big arc, for certain, because as we all know he may very well be a tough/scary guy, but can he possibly be a life-taker as well? We never know, because the investigation takes over several series and we catch slivers of the action. The answer is obviously a dastardly frame and the culprit is also the one, who knows that Bruce Wayne is actually Batman. So, Batman fans of his series, do tell who the bad guy is and whether he gets away or not.

The Art: Year for does have a high amount of artists on board. Guice is nowhere to be seen and the pencils have been taken by:

James Fry [meh]
Rodney Ramos [closer to my personal aesthetics, but not quite there]
Rick Leonardi [basically the same as with the last one]
Glenn Fabry [a bit too retro for my liking and his artwork reminds me of the Watchmen]
Dave Ross [certainly has captivatedme with his lines]
Amanda Connor [first woman on board]

As you can see this is a busy year for DC artists and I also need to emphasize on how this is the year that the series gets to be illustrated by a woman for three issues [Moore’s arc]. You can immediately tell that a woman is doing the lines, because it is definitely girlish, but in the good way. Dead giveaways include the lips and the hair, which resemble how designers draw their fashion sketches. The art clicked with the energetic and slightly good-natured humor from Moore’s side and gave me pure pleasure.

Verdict: While I was reading the issues, I was praying to all gods that the crossovers stop already [they do eventually], but overall became hooked and reading the issues turned more fun rather than a task I set myself to complete every day [with 127 issues, one needs all the stimulation in the world].

Batman in Art

Batman, Batman, Batman. With two modern motion pictures behind us, Batman has entered the mainstream man’s mind further than ever. He is an oldie with first appearance in 1939, but has managed to stay unchanged throughout all these years. Batman is Bruce Wayne, was Bruce Wayne and will remain Bruce Wayne [even if Dick Grayson plays substitute Batman in the DC universe at some point]. I bloody loved the movies, but I can’t say that I like Batman as a character. Even if he is prime example that you do not need big old super powers to stop criminally insane and super powered maniacs, to me he will always remain the a**hole that broods.

The creators behind his dark and gritty personality did a fine job at justifying his behavior, but I find it hard to relate to a character that is intimidating in a cold manner and is not easy to close to. I imagine that perhaps if given the opportunity to start a series with him, I would change my opinion, but that has to happen, when I have nothing else to read and I am not sure whether that is humanly possible for my TBR grows by the second. But never say never. If there is a series you think I should try, give a ring. Anyway, enjoy the cool art treatment he has been subjected to. Artists eat him up like the end is coming.


Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Birds of Prey: Issues #25 to #37 [Jan 01 - Jan 02]

Third year for Birds of Prey, the basis has been established and cemented and the complexity has risen up a few notches, which complicates my function as a reviewer. For the sake of not overly complicating the review and crop some paragraphs meant for transitions I’ll break my thoughts on issues #25 to #37 into several categories. I think it will be quite practical and help me better appreciate the story from all its angles.

Action: After strengthening their partnership after the events from the Blockbuster arc a few issues back, Oracle and Black Canary tackle bigger and more dangerous targets. Barbara’s well established network of connections in the super hero community [Robin, Nightwing, Power Girl, The Blue Beetle, Militia] and Black Canary’s survival instincts and fighting prowess ensure that missions will grow in scale and dynamics and Dixon didn’t let me down. My expectations were met as far as how the series progress as far as kicking-ass is concerned and mind you, that although subtle philosophic, emotional and intelligent undertones are needed to make a comic a worthwhile read, super heroes need their battles.

Dixon supplies those battles. Time traveling and getting to fight alongside Vikings against Native Americans to secure history doesn’t get screwed up? Yes, you have that my friend [even if I am one of those people, who are against time travel as an idea, because it has been done enough already]. Spoiling the wedding between an unsuspecting Black Canary and an ancient evil wizard with custom restoration pools on an exotic island location, know for profuse bloodshed in the past? You got that with all the kicks, fists and gun fire.

Cast Development: Originally, I wanted this to be called simply ‘Emotion’, because Dixon is really trying to shake things up in Oracle’s love life. The woman doesn’t get a break from employing her former fiancĆ© Jason as a P.I. and then working shoulder to shoulder with Dick, who also comes in handy with his gymnastics. Not to mention Ted Kord [The Blue Beetle], with whom there is a spark, but due to the complicated geometric figure that all these relations create, it doesn’t lead to anything but cordial friendship.

There are also small touches here and there between the interactions between Barbara and her men and also some snippets about the lives of these episodic characters, which imply that their roles might expand [they do to be exact]. Oracle is still the main driving wheel, but the personal-life-exploratory limelight happens to fall on Dinah as well, who in the would-be-bride arc is developed more thoroughly. This is the arc with a tough dilemma involved, when both Oracle and Black Canary are hurt and only one can use the custom healing pool. If Black Canary goes in, she will be healed, her ovaries restored and her metahuman power returned. But if Oracle uses it, she will be able to walk again. In the series this is the crucial event, when the special bond between these two women is born and the Birds of Prey gains a whole new dimension. [I bet that you know how this ends, right?]

The Risk: Year three for Birds of Prey picks up steam for DC fans, but for those that are still in the introduction stages and have just that one series to get acquainted with the DC universe; this is a somewhat confusing year. Dixon’s work escalates and gives the readers more intricate and complicated arcs that spread over more issues, but the year is also marked by crossovers all over the DC world, mainly to do with the Bat Family [all series that are in touch with Bat themed and connected to Bat themed vigilantes].

To all hooked on getting on board the Birds of Prey, this review is a kind of warning sign to do their homework as to where this may cross over. The first occurs in the March issue and picks up a story about Catwoman, which has started and is eventually resolved outside Birds of Prey issues. The second concerns a major arc about the Joker taking over the Slab and then supposedly dying from Nightwing’s hand. This takes place around the early winter months and it’s a shame that I don’t know what happens in detail from the other series. But even if one doesn’t have the extra issues to see how the plot lines resolve, a quick Google search will clear all.

Art: Official pencils are handled by Butch Guice, who seems to have grown on me, because either he together with colorist Shannon Blanchard have perfected their styles gradually from the time they are working together or I grew accustomed to their work. I think it’s the former, because the art becomes easier on the eye with every issue. That is until the guest pencillers start making appearances with shocking results. First, it’s Mike Mcdonnell, whole art I think is god awful in the issue he has contributed [I know he is a professional and has his fan base, but I and his lines did not mix]. I’m not sure what to think of William Rosario’s contribution, but it didn’t wow me in any case. James Fry also didn’t push my love buttons and right about now I began to doubt whether DC examined their artists’ portfolio before commissioning them or not. Yes, I am that capricious, when it comes to art. However, Marcus Martin was there to save day with his amazing January 2002 issue, which blew my mind. If I had my way with the series, he would stick with the series to the very end.

[PS: Why is it so excruciatingly hard to locate artists' websites? If anyone finds anything that resembles an official page on any of these guys, post link.]

Verdict: One thumb up with minor inconveniences [the bloody crossovers]. The dialogues still have that sound, which makes you not take the issues seriously, but it’s not jarring and is on its way to being fixed.

Huntress in Art

I decided to swap DC and Marvel every male/female couple, so that I may not seem too favorable of either imprints. Today’s heroine is Huntress, who happens to be one of those two women, two costumes, one codename. The first Huntress is Helena Wayne, the daughter of Catwoman and Batman and first debuted in the late seventies in Earth-2, where the DC Golden Age takes place, but is removed in the mid-80s. After that the Huntress mantle has been taken by Helena Bertinelli, the mafia daughter turned into a righteous [and exceedingly violent] vigilante. Although both Helena’s look alike, the images I am showing are from version 2, which is also the more popular one. In Birds of Prey, Helena certainly is the wild card character, who seems most problematic, but also most changed in a better way after working with Oracle and the Black Canary. There is also that aspect that she is an extremely aggressive woman and there is that raw sexuality about her, which the designers could not neglect, thus giving us the revealing costume, which non-vigilantes might use to make that Halloween night special for their special person… You gotta love costume designers, when it comes to women and spandex/leather as chosen fabric for those long nights fighting crime.

Comics: Art or Story?

Guest post by Hagelrat.

Harry has been kind enough to let me ramble on again on his blog and join in with the Comic Book Appreciation Month. My reading has contained a small proportion of comics and graphic novels over the years, much more poorly represented on my shelves than they are in my affection. That affection goes back to borrowing old X-Men comics from a friend at school and to The Crow which came out towards the end of my school years (which dates me I guess).

Anyway I have been asked to consider the two elements of comics, art vs. story. As a result I have been thinking about what draws me most to a comic or graphic novel.

I'd like to say story. I'd like to say that the plot and characters are important to me in the same way they are in a novel. To some extent that's true. I kill giants (Joe Kelly) has a brilliant, moving story which drew me in and made me cry at one point. Back at school of the borrowed X-men comics the more unusual plot lines (Psylocke and Revanche) were the ones that really absorbed me. Gaiman's Sandman comics are typical of his superb story telling in any medium and James O'Barr's The Crow is as gripping a story of revenge as any I’ve read in a novel. So it's story then that makes a comic stand out for me, makes it stay in my memory and brings me back to it for endless re reading and I have read The Crow many, many times. Without a decent story it’s a moments diversion. At one point I read some of the Chaos comics (stop sniggering) and plot was never their strength really. They were light and fun and silly and mostly death and mayhem but plot and character never struck me as the strong focus. They were a fun diversion and I retain affection for them but they sit gathering dust and are unlikely to ever be reread. The tricky part of a story for comics is that you don't have anything like the number of words to play with. I've recently ordered a graphic novel with no text at all. At time of writing this it still hasn't arrived, so I can't tell you whether it works. I can tell you that for me at least, without a decent story behind it what you have is a bunch of pretty pictures.

As for artwork. I suppose the important thing about artwork to me is that it's right for the story. The artwork tells you whether this is a dark and gothic tale or frivolous and fun. Styles change with new techniques and are by necessity affected by fashions and trends. I remember clearly when Jet Set Radio (game) came out, being blown away by cell shading which I had never really seen before. So it must be with comics, you don't really see people drawing in the style of old Spiderman comics any more; everything is slicker, sharper, cleaner. As for me, well yes, I’m shallow, I like pretty things, I struggled with Watchmen because the art didn't work for me. I love the spikey black and white of both Sandman and The Crow. I loved that I kill Giants managed to be both playful and plangent, which was so perfect for the story. I was drawn to The Untamed by it’s dark strong colours and it’s sense of despair and brutality. I want to feel the world I am being drawn into before I start to read. I don’t think any single thing about the art can be more important than it being evocative of the mood of the comic. It tells you where you are and prepares the mood after all comics don't really allow for long descriptions of mood and set. If you take the words out of the comic completely the art should still be able to carry you through the story so with the wrong artwork the story vanishes and no caption can ever put it right.

Fundamentally, whether in each case it’s to your taste or not, for a comic to work the art and plot must support and compliment each other. If they are at odds then the reader will be pulled in different directions so perhaps the real skill is getting the right combination and balance. It's a symbiotic relationship, a comic with no real story is a picture book, a story without the right artwork will get lost. So what are some of your favourite examples of art and story and what matters most to you?
Related Posts with Thumbnails